The Rise of Agave: NYC’s Best Mezcal & Tequila Cocktails
New York City’s cocktail culture is evolving, and at the heart of this transformation is the growing appreciation for agave spirits. Once overshadowed by whiskey and gin, mezcal, tequila, and sotol are now at the forefront of innovative mixology.
This shift is driven by a desire for bold, complex flavors, as well as an increased appreciation for small-batch, artisanal distilling methods. Agave spirits are no longer just for margaritas—they are being showcased in elevated cocktails, smoky Negroni variations, and sophisticated sipping experiences.
From speakeasies to rooftop lounges, here’s where to find the best mezcal and tequila cocktails in NYC—and how to bring the agave experience to your next event.
The Cabinet Mezcal Bar – An East Village Agave Haven
Location: 649 E 9th St, East Village
Tucked away in the East Village, The Cabinet is a cozy, intimate mezcal bar with a carefully curated selection of agave spirits. Their extensive menu of mezcals and tequilas caters to both novices and seasoned aficionados, with flights available for those looking to explore different regions and styles.
What to Order:
The Oaxacan Old Fashioned – Mezcal, agave nectar, and bitters, served over a large ice cube for a smoky yet smooth take on the classic
House Mezcal Flight – A guided tasting of three different mezcals, offering a deep dive into the complexities of the spirit
Why It Stands Out: The Cabinet offers a true educational experience, making it one of the best places in NYC to explore the world of agave.
Bar Calico – Sotol and Southwest Vibes
Location: 23 Lexington Ave, NoMad
Inspired by the landscapes of the American Southwest, Bar Calico offers a cocktail menu that highlights sotol, a lesser-known agave cousin with an earthy, herbaceous profile. This is the place to try agave spirits beyond the mainstream, all while enjoying a beautifully designed space inspired by artist Georgia O’Keeffe.
What to Order:
Sotol Negroni – Sotol, Campari, and sweet vermouth, giving the classic an herbaceous depth
Jalapeño Cucumber Margarita – A refreshing, slightly spicy take on a tequila staple
Why It Stands Out: One of the few NYC bars focusing on sotol and southwestern flavors, Bar Calico offers a unique take on agave-based mixology.
Leyenda – Brooklyn’s Latin American Cocktail Destination
Location: 221 Smith St, Brooklyn
Founded by acclaimed bartender Ivy Mix, Leyenda celebrates the full range of Latin American spirits, with an emphasis on mezcal and tequila. The cocktails here are deeply rooted in tradition yet modern in execution, and the space itself is warm, lively, and inviting.
What to Order:
Tia Mia – A mezcal take on the Mai Tai, blending smoky and tropical notes
Spiked Mexican Hot Chocolate – A winter favorite, featuring Oaxacan chocolate and a smoky mezcal kick
Why It Stands Out: Leyenda’s cocktails pay homage to Latin American culture, making it a must-visit for those who appreciate authentic flavors and expertly crafted drinks.
Ghost Donkey – NoHo’s Lively Mezcal & Tequila Bar
Location: 4 Bleecker St, NoHo
Ghost Donkey is a fun, energetic mezcal and tequila bar with an impressive collection of agave spirits. Known for its loud, festive atmosphere and over-the-top nachos, it’s the perfect place for a lively night out while sipping on some of the best tequila cocktails in the city.
What to Order:
Mezcal Margarita – A smoky, citrus-forward twist on the classic
Truffle Nachos & Tequila Pairing – Their signature dish, best enjoyed with a neat pour of extra añejo tequila
Why It Stands Out: Ghost Donkey combines high-quality agave spirits with a vibrant, party-like atmosphere, making it a great spot for a night out with friends.
Maya Mezcal – A Hidden Agave Gem
Location: 304 E 6th St, East Village
Maya Mezcal is a lesser-known but deeply loved mezcal bar in the East Village, offering a relaxed setting with over 60 different mezcals and tequilas to explore. The bartenders are passionate about the craft, ensuring each drink is expertly balanced and full of flavor.
What to Order:
Mezcal Mule – A smoky twist on the classic, featuring ginger beer and fresh lime
Agave Tasting Flight – A great way to compare the differences between tequila, mezcal, and sotol
Why It Stands Out: With its laid-back vibe, extensive selection, and knowledgeable bartenders, Maya Mezcal is a hidden treasure for agave lovers.
Bring the Agave Experience to Your Next Event
New York City’s agave renaissance isn’t just happening behind bar counters—it’s something you can bring into your own home, corporate event, or private gathering.
At Art of the Cocktail, we offer:
✔ Private mixology classes where guests learn to craft mezcal and tequila cocktails from scratch
✔ Guided agave tastings featuring rare and small-batch spirits
✔ Custom cocktail experiences inspired by Latin American traditions and NYC’s best agave bars
Whether you're planning an intimate tequila tasting, a festive mezcal-fueled celebration, or a corporate happy hour, our expert mixologists will bring the rich history, flavors, and artistry of agave spirits straight to your event.
Because the best way to celebrate the rise of agave is not just to drink it—but to understand, appreciate, and savor it.
Final Thoughts: NYC’s Agave Revolution Is Here
Agave spirits are no longer just a niche interest—they have become a cornerstone of modern mixology in New York City. From the deep smokiness of mezcal to the complex sweetness of aged tequila, bars across the city are crafting extraordinary drinks that showcase these spirits in new and exciting ways.
Whether you’re sipping a Oaxacan Old Fashioned in a hidden speakeasy, enjoying a sotol Negroni on a rooftop, or learning how to craft these cocktails yourself with Art of the Cocktail, there has never been a better time to explore NYC’s agave scene.
