The Ultimate Guide to Vegan Ice Cream in NYC
Finding truly creamy, satisfying vegan ice cream can be a challenge, even in a city as food-savvy as New York. While many ice cream shops offer a dairy-free option or two, few go beyond the basics to craft rich, flavorful plant-based ice cream that rivals traditional dairy-based scoops.
That’s where Ample Hills Creamery stands out. Known for its handcrafted, small-batch ice cream, Ample Hills is just as passionate about its vegan and dairy-free offerings, ensuring that everyone—regardless of dietary preferences—can enjoy their signature flavors.
If you’re searching for the best vegan ice cream in NYC, look no further. Let’s dive into what makes Ample Hills’ plant-based lineup truly special.
What Makes Ample Hills’ Vegan Ice Cream Different?
Many dairy-free ice creams fall short when it comes to texture and flavor. Some are too icy, others are too thin, and many lack the indulgent, creamy richness that makes ice cream so satisfying. Ample Hills, however, has perfected the art of plant-based ice cream by using high-quality coconut milk and premium mix-ins, resulting in a scoop that’s just as decadent as their traditional offerings.
Unlike other shops that simply remove dairy and call it a day, Ample Hills takes the time to develop complex, well-balanced flavors with thoughtful ingredient pairings. Every scoop is designed to be flavor-forward, creamy, and packed with texture—not just an afterthought for vegan customers.
The Best Vegan Ice Cream Flavors at Ample Hills
Cookies & Cookies & Cream (Vegan)
A plant-based twist on a classic favorite, this coconut-based vanilla ice cream is loaded with Oreo sandwich creme cookies, giving it a crunchy, chocolatey texture that’s hard to resist. If you love cookies and cream but want a dairy-free alternative, this one’s for you.
Fudge Crackle (Vegan)
Chocolate lovers, rejoice. This deep, rich coconut-based chocolate ice cream is packed with crunchy chocolate-coated rice crisps, adding a delightful texture to every bite. Unlike many plant-based chocolates that can be too bitter or too sweet, this one hits the perfect balance.
Underneath the Mango Tree (Vegan, GF)
For those who prefer a fruit-forward scoop, this silky smooth mango sorbet delivers pure tropical bliss. Made with ripe, juicy mangoes, it’s a refreshing option that’s both vegan and gluten-free, making it a great choice for those with multiple dietary restrictions.
Salty Malty (Vegan)
One of the newest additions to the lineup, Salty Malty combines peanut butter and pretzel-infused ice cream with housemade vegan peanut butter cups. The salty-sweet contrast makes it an instant fan favorite among plant-based and non-vegan customers alike.
Where to Find Ample Hills’ Vegan Ice Cream in NYC
One of the best parts about Ample Hills’ commitment to vegan-friendly treats is that you can find their dairy-free flavors at all their NYC locations. Whether you’re stopping by Brooklyn, the Upper West Side, or Astoria, you’ll always have a plant-based option ready to scoop.
Locations:
Upper West Side – 526 Amsterdam Ave, just a short walk from Central Park.
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn – 623 Vanderbilt Ave, the original Ample Hills scoop shop.
Astoria, Queens – 34-02 30th Ave, a neighborhood favorite.
Prospect Heights — 816 Washington Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Looking for vegan ice cream near you? Use Ample Hills’ store locator to find the closest scoop shop!
Why Vegan Ice Cream at Ample Hills is a Must-Try
With so many vegan ice creams on the market, why choose Ample Hills? The answer is simple:
✔ Handcrafted in Small Batches – Ensuring consistent quality and premium flavors. ✔ Unique & Thoughtful Flavor Pairings – No boring sorbets here—only bold, innovative combinations.
✔ Rich, Creamy Texture – Thanks to high-quality coconut milk bases, their plant-based ice cream is as indulgent as dairy-based.
✔ Available at Multiple Locations – No need to search—vegan options are available at every Ample Hills shop.
✔ Loved by Vegans & Non-Vegans Alike – These flavors are crafted to impress all ice cream lovers, not just those avoiding dairy.
Vegan Ice Cream That Stands Out
Ample Hills Creamery has truly redefined vegan ice cream in NYC. Whether you’re dairy-free, vegan, or simply looking to try something new, their plant-based lineup delivers big flavors and creamy textures without compromise.
Next time you’re craving a scoop, don’t settle for just any dairy-free dessert—head to Ample Hills and experience the best vegan ice cream in New York City.
